Two leading Civil Rights organizations in Israel have challenged and condemned an internal investigation by the Israeli military that the killing of four children on a Gaza Beach on July 16, 2014 was not intentional but an “accident.” But eye witnesses say the Israeli soldiers intentionally targeted the four boys, aged 9 to 11 years old, as a part of a widespread Israeli policy of ignoring civilians in their unprovoked war against Palestinians last summer.
By Ray Hanania
Al Mezan, the Center for Human Rights in Israel, and Adalah, the Legal Center for Arab Minority Rights in Israel, both called on the Israeli military to reopen the investigation and denounced the conclusions which asserted the location where the deaths occurred was not being used as a military operation at the time.
Israel has used the internal report, which has been denounced internationally as a “whitewash” of the facts and a conclusion intentionally conceived as a part of Israel’s political propaganda to exonerate itself from its culpability int he murder of nearly 2,200 Palestinians including as many as 500 children during their assault on the Gaza Strip in the summer of 2014.
The Israeli war on the Palestinians also completely destroyed more than 10,000 homes, severely damaged more than 50,000 homes, public buildings and recreational locations, and made more than 300,000 Palestinians homeless.
The four boys were from the same family and were playing on the beach when Israeli soldiers intentionally targeted them with missiles, according to numerous eyewitnesses that the Israeli military refused to call as witnesses. Israel asserted the site was being used as a Hamas armaments station and was filled with Hamas militants, yet no Hamas militants were killed or even injured at the site except children.
Adalah and Al Mezan are two of the most reputable Civil Rights organizations in Israel and Palestine and they have conducted exhaustive investigations into Israeli war crimes instances.
The Israeli report is typical of a government that commits war crimes but is not held accountable by the international community. Both Amnesty International and the United Nations have condemned Israel’s atrocities during the Gaza War. But Israel has hid behind the international protection provided by the United States to keep Israel from being held accountable for its actions.
The International Middle East Media Center (IMEMC) did a comprehensive story on the killings which were among dozens of incidents in which witnesses confirmed that Israeli soldiers intentionally targeted civilians including children during their war against Hamas. Click here for that story.
An Israeli-paid panel of military personnel from politically supportive nations also concluded that Israel did not commit war crimes during the war, another example of Israel’s high-price-tag propaganda and PR Campaign that is bought hook, line and sinker by the brainwashed American public and by many American Jews who have abandoned all pretense of civil rights and defend Israel in the face of even the most heinous of moral and principled atrocities.
Here is the press release from Al Mezan and Adalah which concluded, the “Israeli investigation system is fundamentally flawed. The army cannot investigate itself.”
On Friday 12 June 2015, the Israeli army announced the closure of the investigation file into the killing of four children of the Bakr family – Ahed (10 years), Zakaria (10 years), Mohammed (11 years) and Ismail (10 years) – by an Israeli military rocket attack, while they were playing on the fishermen’s beach in Gaza City, during the War on Gaza last summer, on 16 July 2014.
Immediately following the killings, Al Mezan and Adalah submitted an urgent letter to the Military Advocate General (MAG) demanding an immediate, independent investigation into suspected war crimes. The human rights organizations reject the Israeli army’s closure of the investigation.
Al Mezan and Adalah emphasized that, “Testimonies collected from witnesses confirm that the site of the attack was not being used for military purposes, in stark contrast to the Israeli army’s claims in its report. This site is part of the fishermen’s port, which is adjacent to a coffee shop and next to a number of hotels and an event location. The testimonies show that people who were sitting in the coffee shop were also injured by shrapnel from the attack.”
“Can it be that the Israeli army, with all of its
technologically advanced weapons,
cannot distinguish between armed combatants
and children playing at the seaside?”
Al Mezan, Adalah
In addition, Al Mezan and a large number of press reports confirmed the presence of numerous journalists at the site, which the Israeli army considered to be a Hamas “military outpost”. Tyler Hicks, a New York Times award-winning photographer, who witnessed the killing of the boys, told the British newspaper The Guardian that, “A small metal shack with no electricity or running water on a jetty in the blazing seaside sun does not seem like the kind of place frequented by Hamas militants.” Foreign press sources, who stayed at the site for long periods of time, confirmed that the site was used by fishermen on a consistent basis, and could be easily entered via the public beach of the port.
Al Mezan and Adalah also stressed that, “Even if the Israeli army’s arguments were true, which have clearly been refuted, the Israeli army cannot close the investigation file and clear the military of international humanitarian law violations. Even if the site was sometimes used as a military site, that alone does not justify indiscriminately bombing people located there, especially as Israel has acknowledged that at the time, there were no ongoing hostilities from this site, which is required by international laws of war.” The army’s acknowledgement that there were no combat operations from the site at the time of the bombing alone, argue Al Mezan and Adalah, may be sufficient in finding international humanitarian law violations.
Al Mezan and Adalah also refute the Israeli army’s claims that it was unable to distinguish that the targets were in fact children playing on the beach. Al Mezan and Adalah emphasize that, “The Israeli army’s allegations are illogical. The Israeli army has high technological capabilities, which are able to check the smallest details on the ground. However the army still claims that it did not have the ability in this case to recognize that these small children, without any weapons, are not fighters from the Hamas movement. It is unreasonable that the Israeli army, with all of its capabilities and experience, cannot distinguish between the movement of children playing, and the movement of fighters preparing to carry out combat operations.”
The human rights organizations also stressed that although four witnesses from Gaza gave affidavits, which were submitted by Adalah and Al Mezan to the Military Advocate General’s office, the Israeli army asked only one witness – a child who suffers from post-traumatic stress, according to the medical report that was sent to the MAG – to testify at the Erez checkpoint. The other three witnesses expressed their willingness to give their testimonies, but were never approached. Notably in the press release, the Israeli army stated that witnesses from Gaza who were invited to testify refused to attend. Commenting on this claim, Al Mezan and Adalah highlight that, “Foreign press sources confirm that none of the foreign journalists who witnessed the event at the site, photographed it and wrote about it were summoned for investigation. This showed that the Israeli army has no willingness to uncover the truth of the incident.”
Al Mezan and Adalah added that, “The Israeli army does not mention the torture, ill-treatment and harassment frequently suffered by Palestinians at the Erez crossing at the hands of the Israeli army, including arbitrary arrests, interrogations for long hours and days, and exploitation whereby the army attempts to pressure them to cooperate with the Israeli intelligence agencies. The army uses these practices even against extremely sick patients who come to Erez seeking medical treatment out of Gaza. Knowing all this, how can Palestinian witnesses feel safe going to and trusting the Israeli army, especially when they are submitting testimonies that are against the army itself?”
In this regard, Adalah and Al Mezan emphasized that, “The witnesses’ fear and their refusal to testify to the Israeli army confirms the need for an independent, international investigation, which alone is capable of reaching the truth of what happened in Gaza. The Israeli army’s investigation system lacks independence, impartiality and transparency.”
Al Mezan and Adalah concluded that, “The Israeli army only spoke to and listened to itself in the course of this investigation. The army completely ignored dozens of foreign press witnesses to the event from the site, as it did not ask these journalists to provide their evidence. A fair system does not and cannot investigate itself, and those who commit war crimes cannot hold themselves accountable for those crimes. This case shows that the Israeli investigation system is deeply flawed and contradicts international law and norms of investigation.”
Ray Hanania is an award winning political and humor columnist who analyzes American and Middle East politics, and life in general. He is an author of several books.
Hanania covered Chicago Politics and Chicago City Hall from 1976 through 1992. He began writing in 1975 publishing The Middle Eastern Voice newspaper in Chicago (1975-1977). He later published “The National Arab American Times” newspaper (2004-2007).
Hanania writes weekly columns on Middle East and American Arab issues as Special US Correspondent for the Arab News ArabNews.com, at TheArabDailyNews.com, and at SuburbanChicagoland.com. He has published weekly columns in the Jerusalem Post newspaper, YNetNews.com, Newsday, the Orlando Sentinel, Houston Chronical, and Arlington Heights Daily Herald.
Hanania is the recipient of four (4) Chicago Headline Club “Peter Lisagor Awards” for Column writing. In November 2006, he was named “Best Ethnic American Columnist” by the New American Media. In 2009, Hanania received the prestigious Sigma Delta Chi Award for Writing from the Society of Professional Journalists. He is the recipient of the MT Mehdi Courage in Journalism Award. He was honored for his writing skills with two (2) Chicago Stick-o-Type awards from the Chicago Newspaper Guild. In 1990, Hanania was nominated by the Chicago Sun-Times editors for a Pulitzer Prize for his four-part series on the Palestinian Intifada.
His writings have also been honored by two national Awards from ADC for his writing, and from the National Arab American Journalists Association.
Click here to send Ray Hanania email.
Latest posts by rayhanania (see all)
- Israeli woman refuses to serve in IDF - November 19, 2019
- Arafat’s legacy an inspiration to everyone seeking freedom, justice - November 15, 2019
- Uprising in Lebanon must focus on domestic reform, not on Hezbollah - November 14, 2019