Skip to content
  • Image
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Youtube
  • Podcasts
  • Email
  • Contact
  • Home
  • Opinion
  • News
  • Features
  • Comment
  • Store
The Arab Daily News

The Arab Daily News

Original news, features, opinions from Chicago to Jerusalem

  • About
    • About
    • Our Writers
    • Subscribe to Ray’s Columns
    • Book Store
    • Contact
    • Submit Book Reviews, Press Releases
    • Advertise
    • Privacy Corrections Policy
    • Profile on Ray Hanania
    • Submit Press Release
  • Features
    • Food
    • Book Review
    • Humor
    • Movies
    • Travel
  • Arab Stores Targeted
  • Arab Community Network Page
    • Arab Community Network Page
    • Arab Heritage America resources
    • Directory
      • Groups & Organizations
      • Mosques, Churches
      • Restaurants
      • 2008 & 2014 Arab Media Directories
    • National Arab Heritage Month
    • Video: Chicago Arab History
    • Video: Photo Array of Chicago Arabs
    • Overview of Arabs in America
    • Hanania standup comedy
    • Arabs on the Titanic
    • Obituaries
  • Podcasts
    • Arab News Ray Hanania Radio
    • Ray Hanania on Politics Podcast
    • Podcast Info
    • Hanania Podcast intro
    • Live Arab Radio
  • Your Views
  • Hanania on Tiktok
  • Toggle search form
  • Arab Democratic Club Feb 12, 2023 Forum & Brunch flier
    Arab Democrats host forum for Chicago and suburban candidates Feb. 12 American Arabs
  • The Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) announced Dr. Manal Fakhoury has been elected to the position of Chair of the National Board of Directors, and that attorneys Spojmie Nasiri of California and John Floyd of Texas have joined the organization’s National Board.
    CAIR Announces Dr. Manal Fakhoury as New Board Chair, New Board Members Spojmie Nasiri and John Floyd American Arabs
  • AHRC Executive Director Imad Hamad
    AHRC: Honor Dr. King Day with Civility, Unity, and Action American Arabs
  • Citgo Gas Station and Quik Mart at 3759 W. Chicago Ave in Chicago ordered closed by Mayor Lori Lightfoot because a street gang member with an AK-47 killed someone in front of the store. Only Arab and Muslim stores are being closed by the Mayor
    When Chicago Mayor Lori Lightfoot targeted Arab businesses in 2021 and 2022 Activism
  • Hussam al-Mayman, The Mayman Show, podcast Arab News
    Arab News launches third season of The Mayman Show podcast Arab News
  • State Rep. Cyril Nichols interviewed on live Arab American radio in Detroit with host Ray Hanania Friday Dec. 9, 2022
    Nichols discusses need to improve Arab-Black relations in Chicagoland American Arabs
  • Voting sticker issued to voters in Cook County elections in 2016. Photo courtesy of Ray Hanania
    Gov. Pritzker Announces Six Appointments to Boards and Commissions — no Arabs included American Arabs
  • Closure notice posted on the doors and windows of Arab American businesses during Mayor Lori Lightfoot's closure of Arab owned stores in June - Sept. 2021. Photo courtesy of Ray Hanania
    Pritzker again ignores needs of Arab businesses in latest appointments Activism
  • Arab American Democratic Club (AADC) official candidate endorsements for the November 8, 2022 General elections.
    Arab American Democratic Club issues endorsements for Nov. 8, 2022 Cook County Illinois elections Activism
  • Arab Democrats urge NO VOTE on Gov. J.B. Pritzker re-election bid Activism
  • Assyrian American GOP issues endorsements in Nov, 8, 2022 elections
    Assyrian American GOP group endorses candidates in Illinois Activism
  • Abdullah Hammoud, elected Mayor of Dearborn Nov. 2, 2021. Photo courtesy of Abdullah Hammoud Facebook Page
    AHRC’s 2022 Spirit of Humanity Gala a Great Success American Arabs
  • Interlink 2022 Cookbooks Make the Best Holiday Gifts
    Interlink 2022 Cookbooks Make the Best Holiday Gifts Arab World
  • Rep. Cyril Nichols to be feted by supporters at fundraiser Saturday Oct. 22 Activism
  • Stand up For Human Rights website, United Nations
    UN experts condemn Israel’s ‘sadistic’ punitive measures against French-Palestinian rights defender Salah Hammouri Activism
Analyst Jerome Segal

A Better Response to Bennett’s “Terror State” Claim

Posted on November 5, 2021November 5, 2021 By News Editor News Editor No Comments on A Better Response to Bennett’s “Terror State” Claim
SHARE ...
          
 
  

  • Tweet

A Better Response to Bennett’s “Terror State” Claim

Whether the two-state solution is dead or merely in a coma remains an open question. But if serious negotiations ever do return, if they are to succeed, they will have to grapple with the real possibility that in an independent Palestinian state, Hamas could come to power by democratic means. It is both morally and strategically untenable that a peace agreement rests upon postponing Palestinian democracy indefinitely. 

By Jerome M. Segal

Analyst Jerome Segal
Analyst Jerome Segal

At their joint press conference at the close of German Chancellor Merkel’s recent visit to Israel, Prime Minister Bennett pushed back on Ms. Merkel’s support for the two-state solution to the conflict. Bennett said, “A Palestinian state would mean a terror state” and that it would “be established roughly seven minutes from my house and almost any point in Israel.”

The Palestinian response was quick, with a PLO spokesman saying “The worst form of terrorism is the occupation, not the establishment of a Palestinian state.”   But more than this is needed.

While Bennett’s comments about a terror state are, in  good part, rationalization for his ideological determination to extend Israeli sovereignty to the West Bank, for most Israelis the terror state concern is genuine.

Whether the two-state solution is dead or merely in a coma remains an open question. But if serious negotiations ever do return, if they are to succeed, they will have to grapple with the real possibility that in an independent Palestinian state, Hamas could come to power by democratic means. It is both morally and strategically untenable that a peace agreement rests upon postponing Palestinian democracy indefinitely. 

Future Israel-PLO negotiations, if they are serious, will have to provide the Israeli public with a basis for believing that a potential Hamas government would view itself as bound by the terms of an agreement it opposes. While PLO negotiators may not worry about such eventualities, Israelis will, and unless there is a solution, it is not likely an agreement will be reached in the first place.

Israeli Prime Minister Naftali Bennett. Photo courtesy of Wikipedia
Israeli Prime Minister Naftali Bennett. Photo courtesy of Wikipedia

Is there anything that would make it more likely that an elected, but ideologically unchanged,  Hamas government would abide by the terms of a PLO-negotiated treaty that proclaimed the end of the conflict?

In considering this we must go back to 2006 and the Hamas victory in the elections for the Palestinian Parliament. This was a period in which the Hamas-Fatah competition was increasingly intense, with armed clashes a regular occurrence.  In May 2006, six weeks after Hamas won the Parliamentary elections of the Palestinian Authority, a document was signed by  leaders of five Palestinian factions (Fatah, Hamas, Islamic Jihad, PFLP and DFLP) who were being held in Israeli prisons. Referred  to as “The Prisoners’ Document,” this National Conciliation Document sought to achieve Palestinian unity, affirming core principles, affirming the centrality of the PLO and proposing reforms of the PLO that would bring into the PLO, factions that were outside its broad umbrella (e.g. Hamas).

Most interestingly in paragraph 7, the Document affirmed the authority of “the PLO and the President of the PNA” to conduct negotiations with Israel, but specified that “any final agreement must be presented to the new PNC for ratification or to hold a general referendum wherever it is possible.” The PNC (Palestine National Council) is the PLO parliament and the ultimate authority for the organization.

Subsequently, a month later, Hamas and Fatah agreed on a slightly revised document, with almost no change to this paragraph. The revised version read, “Any agreement must be presented to the new PNC for ratification or a general referendum to be held in the homeland and the Diaspora . . . .” The new specification, “and the Diaspora” emphasized the importance of approval by the refugees, worldwide.

Hamas’s agreement to a process of ratification of a treaty negotiated by the PLO came in the context of the imposition on the newly elected Hamas government of Quartet  (US, UN, EU and Russia) conditions for foreign assistance.  The three conditions, framed as “principles,” were 1) non-violence 2) recognition of Israel, and 3) acceptance of previous agreements [made by the PLO] and their obligations. The conditions were not well thought out, and while Hamas was eager to be given a chance to rule, there was no likelihood that they would meet them. However, in accepting the Prisoners’ Document, Hamas, rather than dealing with past agreements, took a future-oriented stance when it committed to acceptance of a PLO-negotiated peace agreement if it were approved in a referendum. This, rather than the three Quartet conditions, is what a viable peace process really needed from Hamas.  It was one of the greatest policy errors of the Quartet, and primarily of the U.S., that the significance of the Fatah-Hamas agreement was not appreciated.

Subsequently Hamas leaders have re-affirmed the ratification-by-referendum framework as one that would be binding on the organization. In early 2007, Fatah and Hamas formed a short-lived unity government and one of the elements of their government platform was a re-affirmation that negotiations would be carried out by PLO Chairman Abbas, but that any agreement had to be submitted to a referendum. Indeed, the platform went further and affirmed that a law would be adopted laying out the procedures for such a referendum. This too was largely ignored.

Nonetheless, Hamas did not abandon its commitment to abide by a referendum on a PLO negotiated agreement. Thus, in 2010, Ismail Haniyeh, who in 2006 became Prime Minister of the Palestinian Authority, at a press conference stated, “Hamas will accept the results (of a referendum) regardless of whether it differs with its ideology and principles” provided that it included all Palestinians in the West Bank, Gaza and the diaspora. [i]

And in March 2014, The Times of Israel, in an article entitled “Hamas Would Accept Peace With Israel, West Bank Leader Says” [ii]  reported that Sheik Hassan Yousef stated, “It is our right to oppose an agreement that [PA President] Mahmoud Abbas brings, like you have your own opposition, but I stress here: We will accept the results of a national referendum and the decision of the majority.”

Neither Israel nor the U.S. ever made any effort to strengthen the Hamas commitment. It was completely ignored, perhaps even below the level of their awareness.  Former Assistant Secretary of State, Elliott Abrams, in “Tested by Zion,” his detailed book about the workings of the Bush Administration in that period, doesn’t even mention the ratification by referendum agreement reach by Fatah and Hamas.

Yet even today, it is not too late to build on Hamas’ commitment to abide by a referendum. Three objectives should be pursued.  First to bring this commitment into the present. Second, to place it on a stronger footing than merely a Fatah-Hamas agreement.  Rather, abiding by a referendum should be seen as necessitated by respect for the right of the Palestinian people to self-determination. And third, to achieve an international consensus that fidelity to this commitment to abide by a ratified end of conflict agreement is the core demand on Hamas, not its recognition of Israel, nor a transformed ideology.

These goals can be fruitfully advanced through action by the United Nations. If there is U.S. support, it can be taken up by the Security Council. Alternatively, with or without U.S. support, through the General Assembly. If the latter, Iran would likely vote for it, with some positive effect from its commitment to not aid efforts to undo a referendum-endorsed peace between Israel and the Palestinians

Here is what the Security Council might affirm:

UN Resolution on Palestinian Referendum

The Security Council,

  1. Deeply concerned to advance movement towards a just resolution of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict;
  2. Affirming the right of the Palestinian people to self-determination;
  3. Aware of the provisions of the Palestinian Prisoners Document of 2006 which identified a referendum of the Palestinian people as a vehicle for conferring ratification upon any peace agreement negotiated between the Government of Israel and the PL0;
  4. Further aware that in subsequent negotiations between Fatah and Hamas, similar agreement was reached that a peace agreement approved in a referendum of the Palestinian people including the Diaspora would thereby receive necessary ratification;
  5. Resolves that any peace agreement between Israel and the Palestinians that is affirmed by a referendum of the Palestinian people is to be deemed an expression of the self-determination of the Palestinian people;
  6. Further resolves that any such ratified peace agreement must thus be respected by all nations and non-state actors.

So worded, the resolution does not call on any party to take any immediate steps. It is an international statement of principle that establishes, for state and non-state actors, a norm to govern behavior in the event that the Palestinian people affirmed a peace agreement.

The passage of such a resolution, in itself, will not erase Israeli fears about what might happen if there is a Hamas-led Palestinian state, but it is a fundamental starting point for addressing the misconception that Hamas cannot be bound by a peace agreement Israel negotiates with the PLO. Moreover, it is very low hanging fruit; such a resolution would not face any serious opposition at the UN, and conceivably could win unanimous support of the world body. As follow up, the Quartet should revisit its conditions for assistance to a Palestinian unity government. The broader thrust of policy should be to promote movement of the two largest Palestinian factions, Fatah and Hamas, into a coherent framework of governance, one that lays the foundation for a time at which Hamas will be allowed to function as a political party, to compete for power democratically, and to actually govern if it is successful, but to govern within the constraints of an end of conflict agreement with Israel legitimized through the referendum process.

(Jerome M. Segal is the Director of The Peace Consultancy. This article is adapted from his forthcoming book, “The Olive Branch From Palestine: The Palestinian Declaration of Independence and the Path Out of the Current Impasse,” Univ. of California Press. email him at Jerome@jeromesegal.org.)

(This Op-Ed first appeared in al-Quds (Jerusalem) in Arabic Oct. 29, 2021. It is reprinted by permission of the author.)

FootNotes

[i] Reuters, “Hamas Would honor referendum  on peace with Israel,” December 1, 2010.

[ii] Reported by Avi Issacharoff, Times of Israel, March 25, 2014.

 

  • Author
  • Recent Posts
News Editor News Editor
News Editor News Editor
News Editor News Editor
Latest posts by News Editor News Editor (see all)
  • Arab News launches third season of The Mayman Show podcast - December 15, 2022
  • This Thanksgiving, let’s use our Blessings for good - November 23, 2022
  • The Road Ahead for Jordanian Youth - November 15, 2022

  • Tweet

SHARE ...
          
 
  
 
          
 
 Tweet 
Bloggers, Commentary, Israel, Opinion, Palestine & Jordan Tags:Hamas, Israel, Israelis, Jerome Segal, Naftali Bennett, Palestine, Palestinians, peace, Resolutions, terrorism, Two-State Solution, United Nations, violence

Post navigation

Previous Post: A new high school model for the 21st century
Next Post: More than $750,000 refunded to Arab property owners in County Treasurer Maria Pappas and Arab Chamber program

Related Posts

  • Israel’s snub of Carter is a rejection of peace Arab World
  • AAI Launches voter information hotline American Arabs
  • Adalah Logo
    Adalah: Arab leader released from detention Civil Rights
  • Auschwitz concentration camp, arrival of Hungarian Jews, Summer 1944 (Photo credit: Wikipedia)
    65 Israeli Laws that target and discriminate against non-Jews in Israel Arab News
  • Ashrawi warns Israel destroying Christian presence in the Holy Land at Middle East Christian confab American Arabs
  • Churches for Middle East Peace (CMEP) Jennifer Maidrand as the Outreach Manager
    Churches for Middle East Peace (CMEP) Announces New Outreach Manager and Other Staff Activism

More Related Articles

What Muhammad Ali meant to American Arabs, and me American Arabs
Sharon Brannigan Facebook Post June 20, 2017 A letter from a reader on the Brannigan controversy American Arabs
Did Islamic terrorists crash the Malaysian plane MH370? Ali Younes
Caterpillar D9 Tractor parked outside an Israeli settlement on lands confiscated by Israel from Palestinian civilians (Wikipedia) APN to US Jewish Groups: Tell Netanyahu to Reverse New Settlement Plans  Israel
Defending American lives, only when it’s politically convenient American Arabs
English: Detailed map of Israeli settlements on the West Bank, January 2006. Produced by the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs - public UN source. Map Centre: http://www.ochaopt.org/?module=displaysection§ion_id=96&format=html (Photo credit: Wikipedia) EU, France, Ireland urge decisive action to block Israeli annexation of West Bank Arab World

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

  • OPINION COLUMNS
  • Tiktok.com/@RayHanania
    Israeli-push behind effort to ban Tiktok in the United States
    January 19, 2023
  • Ghassan Rubeiz
    To what extent is Hezbollah responsible for the current crisis in Lebanon?
    January 17, 2023
  • Image from Rashid-al-Din Hamadani's "A Compendium of Chronicles. Image courtesy of Wikipedia
    Why allow religious extremists to re-define Islam in the West?
    January 10, 2023
  • CAIR Executive Director and co-founder Nihad Awad
    This Thanksgiving, let’s use our Blessings for good
    November 23, 2022
  • NEWS
  • Arab Democratic Club Feb 12, 2023 Forum & Brunch flier
    Arab Democrats host forum for Chicago and suburban candidates Feb. 12
    January 18, 2023
  • The Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) announced Dr. Manal Fakhoury has been elected to the position of Chair of the National Board of Directors, and that attorneys Spojmie Nasiri of California and John Floyd of Texas have joined the organization’s National Board.
    CAIR Announces Dr. Manal Fakhoury as New Board Chair, New Board Members Spojmie Nasiri and John Floyd
    January 12, 2023
  • AHRC Executive Director Imad Hamad
    AHRC: Honor Dr. King Day with Civility, Unity, and Action
    January 11, 2023
  • Citgo Gas Station and Quik Mart at 3759 W. Chicago Ave in Chicago ordered closed by Mayor Lori Lightfoot because a street gang member with an AK-47 killed someone in front of the store. Only Arab and Muslim stores are being closed by the Mayor
    When Chicago Mayor Lori Lightfoot targeted Arab businesses in 2021 and 2022
    January 4, 2023
  • NEWSWIRE
  • Arab Democratic Club Feb 12, 2023 Forum & Brunch flier
    Arab Democrats host forum for Chicago and suburban candidates Feb. 12
    January 18, 2023
  • The Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) announced Dr. Manal Fakhoury has been elected to the position of Chair of the National Board of Directors, and that attorneys Spojmie Nasiri of California and John Floyd of Texas have joined the organization’s National Board.
    CAIR Announces Dr. Manal Fakhoury as New Board Chair, New Board Members Spojmie Nasiri and John Floyd
    January 12, 2023
  • AHRC Executive Director Imad Hamad
    AHRC: Honor Dr. King Day with Civility, Unity, and Action
    January 11, 2023
  • Stand up For Human Rights website, United Nations
    UN experts condemn Israel’s ‘sadistic’ punitive measures against French-Palestinian rights defender Salah Hammouri
    October 19, 2022

Creative Commons License
All work on this website is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. Do not edit original work. Give credit to the original source.

  • 08-09-21-Ziyad-Ad-Pantry-essentials.jpg
  • ZiyadBrandLogo-2016BlackRedBackgrnd.jpg
  • 08-09-21-Ziyad-Sices-Ad.jpg
  • BOOK REVIEWS
  • Interlink 2022 Cookbooks Make the Best Holiday Gifts
    Interlink 2022 Cookbooks Make the Best Holiday Gifts
    October 24, 2022
  • Stories My Father Told Me by author and artist Helen Zughaib, book cover. Photo courtesy of Cune Press
    Stories My Father Told Me by author and artist Helen Zughaib
    November 1, 2021
  • ENTERTAINMENT
  • Hussam al-Mayman, The Mayman Show, podcast Arab News
    Arab News launches third season of The Mayman Show podcast
    December 15, 2022
  • Interlink 2022 Cookbooks Make the Best Holiday Gifts
    Interlink 2022 Cookbooks Make the Best Holiday Gifts
    October 24, 2022
  • Comedian Ramy Youssef courtesy of his Facebook Page: https://www.facebook.com/ramysfaceboo/
    “Ramy” cable series melds Arab world reality with every day American life
    October 22, 2022
  • The Ray Hanania Radio Show Live Wed 5 PM EST in Detroit, Washington DC, Ontario and on Thursday in Chicago. Watch the program live at Facebook.com/ArabNews
    Second Season of “The Ray Hanania Show” Arab American radio launches April 6
    April 4, 2022
  • American Arab CHamber President HassanNijem accepts the Proclamation from Chicago Ald. Roderick Sawyer at the Chamber dinner March 30, 2022
    Chicagoland celebrates Arab American Heritage Month
    March 31, 2022
  • New-iTunes-1400-x-1400-The-Ray-Hanania-Show-Podcast-Icon-300-x-300.jpg
  • The-Kings-Pawn-Book-300-x-300.png
  • Podcast-iTunes-Logo-Chi-City-Hall-1985.jpg
  • terroristbookcover-300-x-300.jpg
  • powerpr300x300ad.jpg
Arab News Newspaper Logo
Read the Arab News, the leading English language newspaper in the MIddle East

Follow Ray Hanania at Gab.com, MeWe.com and IDobbinate.com, the alternatives to Facebook and Twitter Censorship.

Click here to get information on The Ray Hanania Radio Show and its podcasts

Copyright © 2023 The Arab Daily News.

Powered by PressBook Premium theme