Skip to content
  • Image
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
  • Youtube
  • Podcasts
  • Email
  • Subscribe to Ray’s Columns
  • Contact
The Arab Daily News

The Arab Daily News

Original news, features, opinions from Chicago to Jerusalem

  • About
    • About
    • Our Writers
    • Book Store
    • Contact
    • Submit Book Reviews, Press Releases
    • Privacy Corrections Policy
    • Profile on Ray Hanania
    • Submit Press Release
  • Features
    • Food
    • Book Review
    • Humor
    • Movies
    • Travel
  • Arab US Community
    • Arab Stores Targeted
    • Arab Community Network Page
    • Arab Heritage America resources
    • Directory
      • Groups & Organizations
      • Mosques, Churches
      • Restaurants
      • 2008 & 2014 Arab Media Directories
    • National Arab Heritage Month
    • Video: Chicago Arab History
    • Video: Photo Array of Chicago Arabs
    • Overview of Arabs in America
    • Hanania standup comedy
    • Arabs on the Titanic
    • Obituaries
  • Podcasts
    • Ray Hanania on Politics Podcast
    • Arab News Ray Hanania Radio
    • Arab Radio Podcast intro
    • Radio Baladi Detroit
    • TwoGuys on Politics
  • Ray on Tiktok
  • Subscribe Ray’s Columns
  • Archive 2004-2013
  • Toggle search form
  • Ahead of Election, Brooklyn Rallies Outside Leader Hakeem Jeffries’ Office, Demanding He Cut Funding for the War on Iran
    As Congress Returns, Brooklyn to Deliver a Mandate for Peace to Leader Hakeem Jeffries Activism
  • Combatants for Peace founders
    After a powerful and inspiring ceremony, at this 20-year milestone, we are honored to share this message from Combatants for Peace Activism
  • New Israel Fund Acting CEO Mickey Gitzin
    New Israel Fund leader urges Jews and Palestinians to unite against extremism, condemns Israeli government’s actions in Gaza Activism
  • Maria Pappas poses with Salman Aftab with her new memoir "Maria the Pappas" at the Sabeel Center in Des Plaines, Illinois on Oct. 11, 2026
    Maria Pappas shares stories of hardship, faith, and Hope behind new memoir at Pakistani-American Community gathering Activism
  • Mazen Doleh Maria Pappas Hassan Nijem book signing Oct. 10. 2026
    Maria Pappas shares immigrant roots, personal tragedies and lessons of faith at Arab American community book signing American Arabs
  • V4 ACW Partnership Banner 1.jpg 1024X1024
    Arab Center features analysis on what Iran Reveals about China’s Middle East Strategy Arab Center Washington DC
  • 10-10-26 Maria Pappas Arab community book signing
    American Arab Chamber and Palestine Club host book signing for Maria Pappas American Arabs
  • 09-07-26 Arab Center Banner 300x300_Pal_Conf_2
    Latest Analysis from Arab Center Washington DC: Reading Palestinian Polls—and Misreading Palestinian Politics Arab Center Washington DC
  • Arab AMerican Journalist Ali Younes (Photo courtesy of Ali Younes Twitter account)
    American Arab journalist faces imprisonment in Jordan for allegedly sharing Twitter post critical of the Arab country American Arabs
  • John Zogby Strategies logo
    Democrat Socialist label not undermining Democrat vote in November Election
  • Mohammed Faheem Graphic
    Supporters rally for region’s only radio show on national politics, and Arab and Muslim issues Activism
  • Arab Center Washington DC analyst Virginie Collombier
    Arab Center Washington DC spotlights analysis of the challenges facing Libya’s government Arab Center Washington DC
  • Human Rights Without Frontiers website graphic
    International Rights Groups Raise Alarm Over Freedom of Religion and Expression in South Korea Activism
  • HRWF Associate Director Hans Noot was joined by human rights scholars including CAP Liberté de Conscience (CAPLC) President Thierry Valle, FOREF Germany Executive Director Michael Langhans, CESNUR Managing Director and Editor-in-Chief of “Bitter Winter” Massimo Introvigne, and CESNUR Deputy Director Mark Nemes.
    International Human Rights experts call for religious freedom and due process in South Korea Activism
  • Iran flag. Photo courtesy fo Pixabay.com. pixabay.com/fr/photos/iran/
    UN experts alarmed by renewed escalation of hostilities in Iran, call for accountability Human Rights

Israel State Attorney says social media censorship by government is illegal

Posted on November 28, 2019 By rayhanania No Comments on Israel State Attorney says social media censorship by government is illegal
SHARE ...
          
 
  

  • Tweet





Click here to subscribe FREE to Ray Hanania's Columns

Israel State Attorney says social media censorship by government is illegal

Israel State Attorney claims censorship of social media content, following Cyber Unit requests, isn’t an ‘exercise of gov’t authority.’ Adalah & ACRI petition Supreme Court arguing that the Internet Referral Unit cannot submit “voluntary” requests in order to bypass the law.

Following two years of complaints by Adalah that the Israeli Cyber Unit – an internet referral unit operating by the Israeli prosecution since 2015 – was unlawfully issuing requests to social media providers to censor content on their websites, the State Attorney’s office responded on 21 November 2019 that these requests “do not constitute an exercise of governmental authority.” According to the office, the unit only makes “voluntary” requests to censor content while the decisions are ultimately made by the social media providers.

The mechanism for issuing these requests, referred to by the State Attorney’s office as “Alternative Enforcement on a Voluntary Track” (henceforth “Alternative Enforcement”), includes appeals to content intermediaries like Facebook and Google to remove, restrict or suspend access to certain content, pages or users. These requests are based on an alleged violation of domestic laws as well as the intermediaries’ own Terms of Service (ToS).

This form of censorship is conducted without any legal procedure and without granting targeted users the right to be heard in the decision, and is sometimes implemented without the users’ knowledge. Adalah and ACRI argued that the prosecution’s cyber unit cannot submit “voluntary” requests to bypass constitutional and administrative norms, including transparency and due process.

Adalah Logo

CLICK HERE  to read the latest Adalah letter to the State Attorney, 21 November 2019 (in Hebrew) CLICK HERE to read the State Attorney’s response, 21 November 2019 (in Hebrew) 

In light of the State Attorney’s response, Adalah and the Association for Civil Rights in Israel (ACRI) filed a petition on 26 November 2019 to the Israeli Supreme Court demanding that it order the Cyber Unit to end its practices. Adalah Attorneys Fady Khoury and Rabea Eghbariah argued in the petition that the “Alternative Enforcement” mechanism violates the constitutional rights to freedom of expression and due process, that it lacks legal authority, and that it cannot stand constitutional scrutiny under Israel’s Basic Laws.

CLICK HERE to read  Adalah and ACRI’s petition (in Hebrew) A meteoric rise in requests to remove content                                      

The petition emphasized that there has been a vast increase in the use of the Alternative Enforcement mechanism since the Cyber Unit was established in 2015. According to a 2018 report by the State Attorney’s office, the number of requests made by the unit to remove content leaped from 2,241 in 2016, to 12,351 in 2017, to 14,283 in 2018 – an increase of over 600%. This number does not reflect the actual number of targeted content, as each appeal, most of which were addressed to Facebook (87%), may include tens or even hundreds of targeted posts.

The overwhelming majority of requests for content removal were accepted by the social media providers. In the past two years, according to the State Attorney’s report, about 90% of the targeted content were completely or partially removed, most of them on grounds of “identifying with a terrorist organization” (73%) or “incitement offenses” (26%). Only a fraction of the requests (1%) involved incitement to racism, privacy violations, the Video Act (relating to the Prevention of Sexual Harassment Law), copyright infringement, advertising prostitution services, and others.

 Censorship in the dark 

Aside from the data in the State Attorney’s report, there is no other available information on the nature of the content requested for removal by the Cyber Unit. The State Attorney’s office rejected Adalah’s appeals to disclose the content that was removed at the Cyber Unit’s request, and it is apparent from the replies that the office does not keep a record of this content.

Similarly, following a Freedom of Information request submitted by a number of organizations including ACRI, the Israeli Ministry of Justice refused to disclose the content that was removed, claiming that “exposing the content of posts related to incitement to violence and terrorism may harm various security interests.”

Therefore, removing content through the “Alternative Enforcement” mechanism is carried out with no transparency or legal procedure whatsoever, and with no framework for users to defend themselves against allegations that their posts were illegal or warranted removal.

In light of these facts, Adalah and ACRI asked the Supreme Court to issue an interim order requiring the State Attorney’s office to justify the Cyber Unit’s practice (order nisi), and after hearing its position, to issue an order prohibiting the practice.

 Adalah Attorney Rabea Eghbariah commented:

“The mere idea that the state is operating a unit which examines and flags content for ‘voluntary’ removal according to the companies’ own Terms of Service is absurd. The Ministry of Justice is suddenly transformed into the “Ministry of Truth,” constitutional norms replaced with “Terms of Service “, and the courts with corporate clerks. All this is practiced without any legal authority or legal processes whatsoever, in the total absence of transparency, and while exploiting the state’s bargaining power as a potential regulator of these companies. This policy contravenes the principles of the rule of law in an unprecedented manner under the guise of “combating incitement and terrorism,” and violates freedom of political expression. Moreover, there is a reason to suspect that the victims of these violations are first and foremost Palestinian.”.

Case Citation: HCJ 7846/19 Adalah The Legal Center for Arab Minority Riights in Israel v. The State Attorney – Cyber Unit Related Press Releases:Social media giants continue to collaborate with Israel’s illegal ‘Cyber Unit’, 19 December 2018Israel’s Cyber Unit operating illegally to censor social media content, 14 September 2017





Click here to subscribe FREE to Ray Hanania's Columns

  • About
  • Latest Posts
rayhanania
rayhanania
Op-Ed writer, author, radio host, podcaster at The Arab Daily News
Ray Hanania is an award-winning columnist, author & former Chicago City Hall reporter (1977-1992). A veteran who served during the Vietnam War and the recipient of four SPJ Peter Lisagor Awards for column writing, Hanania writes weekly opinion columns on mainstream American & Chicagoland topics for the Southwest News-Herald, Des Plaines Valley News, the Regional News, The Reporter Newspapers, and Suburban Chicagoland.  

His award winning columns can be found at www.HANANIA.COM Subscribe FREE today

Hanania also writes about Middle East issues for the Arab News, and The Arab Daily News criticizing government policies in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.

Hanania was named "Best Ethnic American Columnist" by the New America Media in November 2007, and is the 2009 recipient of the SPJ National Sigma Delta Chi Award for column writing.

Email Ray Hanania at [email protected].

Follow RayHanania at Twitter
rayhanania
Latest posts by rayhanania (see all)
  • Israelisnipers shooting and killing hospital workers in Gaza - December 11, 2023
  • CAIR Condemns Israeli Executions of Wounded, Unarmed Palestinian in West Bank   - December 11, 2023
  • Arab and Muslim American voters face a “simple choice” between Biden’s inhumanity and Trump’s edgy politics - December 9, 2023
NVP: 256

  • Tweet

SHARE ...
          
 
  
 
          
 
 Tweet 
Civil Rights, Israel, News, Palestine & Jordan, Social Media Tags:Adalah, censorship, Facebook, Israel, Israeli Cyber Unit, Palestine, SOcial Media, Twitter

Post navigation

Previous Post: 128 detainees repatriated back to Yemen from Saudi Arabia
Next Post: Book Release: Kettani publishes book about World Muslim Population

Related Posts

  • US Congresswoman Betty McCollum stands with the American Muslims for Palestine in demanding justice and an end to Israeli abuses of Palestinian children. Photo courtesy of Congresswoman Betty McCollum
    Congresswoman McCollum urges end to Israeli abuses of children American Arabs
  • A Third Way, a film that offers hope Arab World
  • Congress and Media must address Israel’s WMD and State Torture of Vanunu Arab World
  • US Congresswoman Btty McCollumn, 4th District, Minnesota. Photo courtesy of McCollum's congressional page
    McCollum praises passage of stimulus payments American Arabs
  • UN vote a slap at Netanyahu than defense of peace American Arabs
  • Illinois Muslim Action Day April 9 2025
    Illinois Muslim Action Day Policies at April 9 Statehouse News Conference American Arabs

More Related Articles

Kayed Fasfous, 32, a father of a seven-year-old from Dura Six Palestinians on hunger strike protesting their administrative detention Arab World
Phantom Pain: An Allies Tale Arab World
Trump resists condemnation of Two-States, predicts peace deal Arab World
Shadin Maali has been named Emgage’s new Senior Director of Growth and Operations Emgage hires former Illinois Congressional aide to help expand their reach Activism
Mahnoor Ahmad Photo courtesy of her website at AhmadforCongress.com Muslim American woman challenges unresponsive Congressman Sean Casten in March 19 Democratic primary Activism
Museum of the Palestinian People, Washington D.C. Museum of the Palestinian People banquet Oct. 3, 2019 Entertainment

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

Arab Center Ad

Order from Amazon.com

Maria the Pappas memoir book cover
CLICK to visit website www.MariaThePappas.com
Mike Porfirio Ad

Ray Hanania Substack Columns

Now that Voters have spoken, Democrats must hear the real message and fix themselves

Now that Voters have spoken, Democrats must hear the real message and fix themselves

04 Nov 2026

The Democrats didn’t win Tuesday. Trump, who said vote like he is on the ballot, lost. Now that Trump has been neutered,...

Don’t let the big money special interests control Chicago’s school board elections

Don’t let the big money special interests control Chicago’s school board elections

03 Nov 2026

Big money doesn’t help to educate the public about candidates and their issues. The wealthy people pump millions into el...

Halloween for today’s kids just isn’t the same as it was for us

Halloween for today’s kids just isn’t the same as it was for us

01 Nov 2026

Today’s Halloween is an example of how the world has changed significantly, and the younger generations don’t even reali...

For Pritzker, money trumps the poor, the Middle Class, and even controversy

For Pritzker, money trumps the poor, the Middle Class, and even controversy

30 Oct 2026

Schlemiels like us average hard working taxpayers are not expected to understand the real factor fueling the egos and th...

Most candidates in MidTerm elections are not addressing the real issues facing voters

Most candidates in MidTerm elections are not addressing the real issues facing voters

21 Oct 2026

Candidates are debating Trump, ICE and partisan politics but are not speaking about the real issues burdening taxpayers;...

New Israel Fund leader urges Jews and Palestinians to unite against extremism, condemns Israeli government actions in Gaza

New Israel Fund leader urges Jews and Palestinians to unite against extremism, condemns Israeli government actions in Gaza

21 Oct 2026

Mickey Gitzin, acting CEO of the New Israel Fund, says peace requires recognizing the suffering of both Palestinians & I...

Click to Read More

Courageous Thought: Hanania Syndicated Columns

Ray Hanania courageous Thought website logo
Ray Hanania

Enter Your Email to Subscribe to Ray Hanania’s Columns

Creative Commons License
All work on this website is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. Do not edit original work. Give credit to the original source. Some photos published with permission from Zemanta and Wikipedia.

Pappas Ad

The Lightning Strike Radio Sun 8-10 AM

Mohammed Faheem The Lightning Strike Radio Show
Mohammed Faheem The Lightning Strike Radio Show
  • NEWS
  • Ahead of Election, Brooklyn Rallies Outside Leader Hakeem Jeffries’ Office, Demanding He Cut Funding for the War on Iran
    As Congress Returns, Brooklyn to Deliver a Mandate for Peace to Leader Hakeem Jeffries
    November 5, 2026
  • Combatants for Peace founders
    After a powerful and inspiring ceremony, at this 20-year milestone, we are honored to share this message from Combatants for Peace
    November 5, 2026
  • Maria Pappas poses with Salman Aftab with her new memoir "Maria the Pappas" at the Sabeel Center in Des Plaines, Illinois on Oct. 11, 2026
    Maria Pappas shares stories of hardship, faith, and Hope behind new memoir at Pakistani-American Community gathering
    October 16, 2026
  • New Israel Fund Acting CEO Mickey Gitzin
    New Israel Fund leader urges Jews and Palestinians to unite against extremism, condemns Israeli government’s actions in Gaza
    October 15, 2026
  • Mazen Doleh Maria Pappas Hassan Nijem book signing Oct. 10. 2026
    Maria Pappas shares immigrant roots, personal tragedies and lessons of faith at Arab American community book signing
    October 12, 2026
  • New-iTunes-1400-x-1400-The-Ray-Hanania-Show-Podcast-Icon-300-x-300.jpg
  • powerpr300x300ad.jpg
  • Podcast-iTunes-Logo-Chi-City-Hall-1985.jpg
  • The-Kings-Pawn-Book-300-x-300.png
  • terroristbookcover-300-x-300.jpg
  • NEWSWIRE
  • Ahead of Election, Brooklyn Rallies Outside Leader Hakeem Jeffries’ Office, Demanding He Cut Funding for the War on Iran
    As Congress Returns, Brooklyn to Deliver a Mandate for Peace to Leader Hakeem Jeffries
    November 5, 2026
  • Combatants for Peace founders
    After a powerful and inspiring ceremony, at this 20-year milestone, we are honored to share this message from Combatants for Peace
    November 5, 2026
  • Maria Pappas poses with Salman Aftab with her new memoir "Maria the Pappas" at the Sabeel Center in Des Plaines, Illinois on Oct. 11, 2026
    Maria Pappas shares stories of hardship, faith, and Hope behind new memoir at Pakistani-American Community gathering
    October 16, 2026
  • New Israel Fund Acting CEO Mickey Gitzin
    New Israel Fund leader urges Jews and Palestinians to unite against extremism, condemns Israeli government’s actions in Gaza
    October 15, 2026

Follow Ray Hanania at
Twitter
Facebook
TitkTok
BlueSky
RayHanania Columns
UpScroll
Threads

Click here to get information on The Ray Hanania Radio Show and its podcasts

Copyright © 2026 The Arab Daily News.

Powered by PressBook Premium theme