American news media exploits Khashoggi torture-killing for their own agenda
The mainstream American news media plays a hypocritical role in managing partisan views of the Middle East and the Arab World. Criticism of the Arab World is heightened but criticism of Israel is suppressed and often whitewashed. The coverage of the murder of Jamal Khashoggi is a good example. Khashoggi’s killing has dominated the news media coverage for two weeks, during which coverage of the killings of Palestinians by Israel has been downplayed, marginalized or not reported at all.
By Ray Hanania
Ray Hanania
A recent story in the New York Times inadvertently raises issues about the hypocrisy of the mainstream news media in championing the details of the tragic torture-murder of Jamal Khashoggi.
The story, published Wednesday, was headlined “How One Journalist’s Death Provoked a Backlash That Thousands Dead in Yemen Did Not.” But as a Palestinian and former journalist who has been a longtime critic of American news media bias, I see it differently.
The mainstream American news media picks and chooses it’s outrageous very carefully. When Khashoggi was a Saudi Royal Family insider, he was just another of the cacophony of voices often ignored by the American press. But when he broke with the Royal Family and became one of their most vociferous critics, suddenly they embraced him, and the Washington Post hired him.
The media hypocrisy is obvious. But the mainstream American news media doesn’t stop there, as the New York Times did in selectively conflating Khashoggi’s horrible and outrageous killing at the Saudi Consulate in Istanbul Turkey on Oct. 2, 2018.
The New York Times, and much of the American news media, has been hinting at the same message: The Arab World is a dangerous place where inhumane torture a bounds and the killing of civilians is a daily occurrence. And yet, they seem to draw a protective circle around one Middle East country, excluding it from similar assertions, Israel.
The New York Times headline could just as easily have been “How One Journalist’s Death Provoked a Backlash That Thousands Dead in Israel Did Not.” That would have more accurately described how Israel has turned the murder of Palestinian civilians into a National Pursuit, which the media has turned a mostly or limited blind eye.
There are ways to kill people in the Middle East if you want to avoid intensive mainstream news media scrutiny, and it’s not just Arab governments who are involved. Israel is the one Middle East nation that seems to be above mainstream American news media scrutiny when it comes to cruelty, murder and horrendous killings.
Although leaked details from Turkey paint a horrendous picture of Khashoggi’s torture and murder, the end result of murder is all the same. Does it really matter if a government torture’s someone to death or indiscriminately shoots someone in the back of the head?
The Israelis have mastered the art of de-criminalizing murder, using several strategies that work. That’s how Israel manages to escape mainstream American new media scrutiny in its constant human rights abuses.
Why kill someone when it is enough to destroy their home, destroy their life, deny their existence and bury them away in a detention camp someplace in the middle of the Negev Desert.
You don’t need to be cruel to achieve your goal. The Israelis have taught the world much about how to murder innocent civilians and get away with it, if you have the complicity of the mainstream American news media.
Put out a press release in English that denounces the victim as a “terrorist.” Accuse of the victim of plotting some outrageous act of violence. Don’t worry about the facts. The accusation and headline are enough.
Give the murder process a fancy name, especially one that sounds like it has legal standing in the International Rule of Law. Something like, “extra-judicial killing.” “Extra-judicial killing” actually sounds like it is a legalized form of human rights protection that involves “extra” concern for justice and the International Rule of Law, apparently to the mainstream America news media which reports on the incidents as if they are justified.
When fancy labels don’t work, all Israel does is call its victims “terrorists.” If the victim is in Gaza, expand the label with the word “Hamas.” Oh yea, “Hamas terrorist” sounds really bad, justifying the murder, right?
The number of labels Israel uses to accommodate American news media complicity is endless. For Israel, managing murder isn’t about stalling, as the Saudis seem to be doing, but rather about defining phrases to accommodate the mainstream American news media’s blindness to Palestinian suffering.
Israel disguises murder for the Western media applying the phrase “human shield.” That’s how they described the killing of Razan al-Najjer who was shot to death by an Israeli soldier sniper along the Gaza border, along with hundreds of other civilians, as she was trying to provide medical attention. Toss in another powerful label, “Hamas operative,” and even the murder of a first responder helping the injured won’t raise mainstream American news media ire.
Another is “collective punishment” which suggests the persons brutalized deserve the violence. The term “collective” is used to disguise the massive extent of the process by which Israel uses to destroy the lives of Palestinians.
Sometimes, you don’t have to actually kill someone to destroy them. All you have to do is take their home, take their lands, expel them, deny them the ability to put food on their table, jail them and shut them up for six to eight months without habeas corpus, an American legal term referring to the right to a public trial.
Then use the labels. Assert that the victims are related to a “terrorist” and that they enabled the terrorist because they are the mother, the father, the sister, the brother. Maybe the infant child. Throw them to the street and watch their lives fall apart slowly but deliberately.
Finally, strip the victims of any and all humanity. Don’t refer to them by name. Don’t provide details of their “life.” Just keep the victims obscured under the various labels like Terrorist, Human Shield, Extra-judicial killing, and terrorist. You can’t over use the word “terrorist” when demonizing opponents.
Instead, provide extensive personal details about the lives, family and loves and wants of the person you are protecting, like the poor Israeli soldier who felt the Palestinian terrorist stabber killer lying on the ground was a threat. Show him with his mother, relatives. Let people into his life, living in fear of Palestinian terrorism.
I know it is hard to believe. But this works. Just ask Israel.
(Ray Hanania is an award-winning Palestinian American syndicated columnist who covered Chicago City Hall and American for more than three decades. His personal website is www.Hanania.com. Email him at [email protected]. This column was first published in the Middle East Monitor.)
Click here to subscribe FREE to Ray Hanania's Columns
His award winning columns can be found at www.HANANIA.COM Subscribe FREE today
Hanania also writes about Middle East issues for the Arab News, and The Arab Daily News criticizing government policies in the Israeli-Palestinian conflict.
Hanania was named "Best Ethnic American Columnist" by the New America Media in November 2007, and is the 2009 recipient of the SPJ National Sigma Delta Chi Award for column writing.
Email Ray Hanania at [email protected].
Follow RayHanania at Twitter
- Israelisnipers shooting and killing hospital workers in Gaza - December 11, 2023
- CAIR Condemns Israeli Executions of Wounded, Unarmed Palestinian in West Bank - December 11, 2023
- Arab and Muslim American voters face a “simple choice” between Biden’s inhumanity and Trump’s edgy politics - December 9, 2023
